Boom Blox is a terrible game to rent.
In the previous generation of consoles, a player could play a game they rented continuously, barring eating, sleeping, and bathroom use. The only thing that player had to contend with is their own will to keep playing. A mental ability.
After the first lengthy session, Boom Blox makes many players reconsider if they want to keep playing due to muscle fatigue. A healthy percentage of gamers could last several lengthy sessions, but the same still results.
Assuming your not ambidextrous or hosting a party, this game may need to skip the renting step.